From The Gold Guys website:
The Gold Guys was ranked the #1 Gold Buyer by Top10Reviews.com in both 2011 and 2012.
We’ve earned that distinction based on process, pricing, reputability, help & support and locations and by being one of the most respected and trusted precious metals dealers in the country.
Which Companies Were Voted Best in 2025? CLICK HERE
Services / Products Available
E-commerce facility
Bullion Bars
Bullion Coins
Numismatic Coins
Investment/Retirement Vehicles
Company Trust Rating
Company established: 2008
Employees: 25-50
BBB rating: A
Other online reviews: B
Bullion.Directory rating: B
Company Alerts
We are not aware of any alerts concerning this company.
In a Nutshell:
The Gold Guys are a large scale local precious metals dealers with 13 retail locations across the US. They are principally gold buyers and buy bullion bars and coins, unwanted jewelry and flatware, watches and diamonds.
Read or add The Gold Guys reviews and ratings using the "reviews" tab above.
All The Gold Guys details are believed to be correct at the time of listing. Please report errors here.
GoldenCrest Metals
Woodbury Gold Vault
Material provided on the Bullion.Directory website is strictly for informational purposes only. The content is developed from sources believed to be accurate at the time of publication; however, no representation or warranty is made as to its completeness or accuracy. No information on this website constitutes investment, financial, tax or legal advice and must not be relied upon as such. Users should consult appropriately qualified professional advisers before making any financial or investment decisions. Precious metals carry risk and may not be suitable for all investors. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Bullion.Directory, its staff, affiliates and associated entities shall not be liable for any loss, damage or loss of profit arising from reliance on information contained on this website or from investment decisions made by readers.
Jeff Olson – :
Coming from Chicago, we were taught not to trust most people so when it came to me trusting someone I had never even met, I had issues. That being said, David was more than willing to walk me through the process even to the point of allowing me to go to the final location. To say the least, he was extremely helpful in this process.
I had found that other’s often charge a percentage of the ‘spot price’, the more the price goes up, the more they take out. The ‘Old Gold Guys’ charge a flat rate, if the price goes up, you get more. I like that.
Overall I’ve found that the ‘Old Gold Guys’ are VERY trustworthy.
Marcus – :
The Gold Guys are my go-to place for unloading jewelry I’ve bought at thrift stores and garage sales. It helps they’re near by but I’ve never been disappointed.
Grant T – :
easy company to work with and good prices offered. Don’t accept their first offer as it can be lowball but stick to your guns and they’ll beat just about anyone
EM – :
So much better than your typical Gold For Cash joint, for starters the staff, for seconds the environment and finally I’d happily be seen going there rather than hiding hoping a colleague or friend doesn’t see me going into some pawn place!
Jer – :
Happy but not delighted with my experience of the gold guys. I had expected more after glowing praise from a close friend, but one of the people i dealt with had a poor attitude. Note I used the Duluth branch not Vegas listed above